Stacey Cartledge 4W1
Football
Inducted 1993 

Wayne Rugg 7W5 
Football-Basketball-Baseball
Inducted 1993

Glenn Stevick 4W0
Football
Inducted 1994

Barry Blundin 8W4
Football-Basketball-Baseball
Inducted 1995

Marty Connor 4W1
Football-Basketball-Baseball
Inducted 1996

Jerry Newswanger 7W2
Cross Country-Basketball-Baseball
Inducted 1997

Clair Newswanger 7W3
Cross Country-Basketball-Baseball
Inducted 1997

William "Doggie" Culbert 3W9
Football-Basketball-Track
Inducted 1998

Miles "Tanker" Miller 3W8
Football-Basketball-Baseball
Inducted 1999

Phil Lock 6W9
Football
Inducted 2000

Richard McKim 6W9
Basketball
Inducted 2000

Joseph Swartzlander 4W0
Baseball
Inducted 2001

Bruce Burrell 5W4
Football-Basketball
Inducted 2002 

Russ Harvey 5W0
Cross Country Coach
Inducted 2004

Mike Neville 0W0
Football
Inducted 2005

Wayne Zimmerman 5W4
Football-Basketball-Baseball
Inducted 2006

Dale Keesey 5W2
Football-Basketball-Baseball
Inducted 2007

Ted Meredith 19W01
Track
1912 Olympic Gold Medalist

Phil Carbonetta 0W2
Wrestling
Inducted 2009

Tim Kilgore 8W9
Football
Inducted 2010

Paul Van Horn 8W4
Football-Basketball
Inducted 2011

Carl Hafer 6W5
Cross Country-Football
Basketball-Baseball
Inducted 2012

Albert Alutius 5W3
Football-Baseball
Inducted 2013

Pat Van Horn 9W1
Soccer-Football-Basketball-Baseball
Inducted 2014

Mike Welch 0W4
Wrestling-Soccer
Inducted 2015

Gerry Neeson 9W3
Soccer-Wrestling
Inducted 2016

Steve Hixson 7W3
Cross Country runner and coach
Inducted 2017

Tommy Arena 6W9
Football-Baseball
Inducted 2018

Davar Watson 1W0
Basketball
Inducted 2019

John Fox 6W9
Football
Inducted 2020

Brian Gougler 9W7
Football-Basketball-Baseball
Inducted 2022

Kevin Brown 0W3
Football-Basketball
Inducted 2022

Justin Swift 1W4
Basketball-Tennis
Inducted 2023

Eric Powell 1W1
Wrestling
Inducted 2024

Dennis "Denny" Ohl 7W4
Football-Baseball
Inducted 2025

Brian Stewart 7W4
Baseball
Inducted 2025